---

Chairperson

1. Introduce yourself

Sir/Ma’am, I come from Punjab. I did my graduation in ______ and have chosen Economics as my optional. I have worked in ______ / or am currently preparing full-time. My interests include ______. I see the Civil Services as a platform to work on governance and development at the grassroots while contributing to nation building.

---

2. Arrange GST, Demonetisation, 1991 reforms, Bank Nationalisation (1969) in order of importance for Indian economy

Order of long-term impact (highest to lowest):

1. 1991 Economic Reforms – Opened the economy, promoted competition, exports, private sector growth → structural & irreversible shift.
2. Bank Nationalisation (1969) – Expanded banking to rural India, deepened financial inclusion, credit access to priority sectors.
3. GST – Created national indirect tax market, improved logistics & compliance, still evolving.
4. Demonetisation (2016) – Short-term shock with objectives of formalisation & digitalisation; long-term impact still debated.

---

3. What reforms could be brought in Civil Services Exam?

• Greater focus on ethics, problem-solving & case-based evaluation
• Psychological + aptitude & situational judgment testing
• Reducing subjectivity in interview through structured rubrics
• Encouraging regional & socioeconomic diversity
• Better focus on communication & field-relevant skills
• Timely exam cycle to reduce uncertainty

---

4. Why was India’s share in world GDP ~33% earlier but ~3% now? How can India regain strength?

Reasons for decline:

• Colonial exploitation & de-industrialisation
• Drain of wealth
• Neglect of manufacturing & handicrafts
• Low investment in education & tech
• Trade restrictions imposed by British
• Population expansion diluting per-capita income

How to regain strength:

• Invest in human capital, innovation & R&D
• Strengthen manufacturing & exports (Make in India)
• Improve infrastructure & ease of doing business
• Promote financial inclusion & digital economy
• Stable macro-economic policies
• Green & inclusive growth

---

Member 1

5. What is Yellow Journalism?

It refers to sensational, exaggerated and unethical reporting focused on creating excitement rather than factual news — often for TRPs or circulation.

---

6. What is Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR)?

It is the ratio of a bank’s capital to its risk-weighted assets.
It shows the bank’s ability to absorb losses and protect depositors.
Regulated under Basel norms.

---

7. What is Bank Recapitalisation? How does the government do it?

Recapitalisation means injecting capital into banks so that they meet regulatory capital requirements and can continue lending.
Government does this by:

• Issuing recapitalisation bonds
• Direct budgetary support
• Allowing market capital raising

---

8. Is it justified to use taxpayers’ money to support weak banks?

Balanced reply:

• Yes, to an extent — protects depositors, avoids systemic risk, maintains confidence.
• But reforms must accompany support — governance improvement, accountability, consolidation, and NPA resolution — so moral hazard does not develop.

---

9. What is Equal Opportunity?

It means everyone gets a fair chance irrespective of caste, gender, religion, disability, or background, especially in education, jobs, and public services.

---

10. What programmes provide Equal Opportunity?

Examples:

• Right to Education
• Reservation policies
• SC/ST/OBC & minority welfare schemes
• Schemes for Persons with Disabilities
• Skill India
• Women empowerment programmes

---

11. Doesn’t Reservation deny equal opportunity?

Reservation actually promotes substantive equality, not just formal equality.
Historically disadvantaged sections need support to compete fairly.
However, periodic review & better targeting are important.

---

12. What reforms could be done in the Reservation system?

• Better socio-economic criteria within categories
• Creamy-layer application & periodic review
• Focus on education & skilling
• Complement reservation with equal quality schooling
• Improve representation in higher posts

---

Member 2

13. Ecological value of mountains & impact of development

Ecological value:

• Water sources (glaciers, rivers)
• Biodiversity
• Climate regulation
• Livelihoods & indigenous habitats
• Disaster buffers

Impact of unplanned development:

• Landslides, erosion
• Flash floods
• Habitat loss
• Urban stress
• Cultural disruption

Balanced development is essential.

---

14. What steps should be taken?

• Scientific land-use planning
• Disaster-resilient infrastructure
• Environmental impact assessments
• Regulated tourism
• Afforestation
• Community-based conservation
• Strict enforcement against illegal construction

---

15. Would you allow the Joshimath hydro-tunnel project if you were in charge?

Sir/Ma’am, I would take a balanced evidence-based approach:

• Conduct independent geological & safety studies
• Prioritise citizen safety over project speed
• Ensure proper compensation & relocation
• Use disaster-resilient design
• If risk remains high → pause or redesign the project

So the decision would be development with safety first.

---

Member 3

16. What is the PAHAL Scheme?

PAHAL (DBTL) — Direct Benefit Transfer for LPG subsidy.
Subsidy is transferred directly into beneficiaries’ bank accounts, reducing leakage.

---

17. What is the Ujjwala Scheme?

Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) provides free LPG connections to poor households, especially women, to shift from biomass cooking to clean fuel.

---

18. Who are beneficiaries under Ujjwala?

Primarily women from BPL households, including:

• SC/ST households
• PMAY households
• Antyodaya families
• Forest dwellers
• SECC-identified poor households

---

19. Why are fuels kept out of GST?

Because:

• Petroleum products are a major revenue source for Centre & states
• States depend heavily on VAT/excise
• Political & fiscal concerns delay inclusion

---

20. What is the impact on oil companies of keeping fuel out of GST?

• Price structure remains complex
• Limited input-tax credit
• Higher compliance burden
• But allows stable revenue for government

---

Member 4

21. State of Indian economy before & after Independence

Before Independence:

• Agrarian, low-productivity economy
• Forced de-industrialisation
• High poverty & inequality
• Very low literacy & infrastructure

Immediately after Independence:

• Economic uncertainty
• Partition shock
• Refugee crisis
• Food shortages
• Weak industrial base
  Hence, planning & self-reliant strategy were adopted.

---

22. What changed immediately after Independence? (They insisted here)

• Adoption of Planned Economic Development
• Creation of public sector enterprises
• Establishment of RBI autonomy, Planning Commission
• Land reforms
• Focus on infrastructure & agriculture

---

23. What was the objective of the Indian freedom struggle?

Beyond political freedom, objectives included:

• Social & economic justice
• Self-governance with dignity
• Democratic rights
• Inclusive development

---

24. Was the objective only Independence or Republic also?

Republic was also an aim — we wanted sovereignty resting with the people, not monarchy or colonial rule.

---

25. What is a Republic? Is the UK a Republic?

A Republic is a state where the head of state is elected or nominated, not hereditary.
The UK is NOT a Republic — it is a constitutional monarchy.

---

26. Which was the First War of Independence?

The 1857 Revolt is popularly termed the First War of Independence (though historians have differing views).

---

27. If India had gained independence in 1857, would it have become a Republic?

Likely not immediately, because:

• National consciousness was still evolving
• Institutions were undeveloped
• Leadership base was limited
  The idea of a modern democratic republic matured later through national movement & constitutional debates.

---

Overall Experience

Your summary already reflects it well — cordial, discussion-oriented, encouraging.

---