Separation of Power Notes for UPSC

Separation of Power Notes upsc

Separation of Power

Introduction

  • It means exe, legislative & judicial powers of Govt shd be divided into diff branches & not concentrated in one. 
  • 1st propounded by Montesquieu in “The spirit of laws”
  • Part of Basic structure—KBC (1973)
  • Functional separation—Art 50, 121 & 211, 122 & 212, 361

India vs USA

  • US–Watertight SoP (Due to Presidential system)
  • Indian constitution embraces idea of SoP in an implied manner—Reasonable & flexible SoP—Principle of “Checks & balances”
      • Bcz of Parliamentary Govt– India does not follow an Absolute separation– Exe is part of legislature & also is responsible to legislature + courts can strike down unconstitutional amendments made by legislature.

Objectives

  • To ensure that diff branches of Govt shd work autonomously with minimal interference from others.
  • Reduces over-centralisation of power in any branch + ensure checks & balance

Importance of SoP

  • Imperative for smooth functioning of vibrant democracy–checks & balances prevent abuse of power
    • GRM through Independent judiciary.
    • Executive remains A/C to Leg for implementation of policies
  • Rule of law + Checks arbitrariness

Functional Overlap

  • Overlapping Powers Of Legislature

With Judiciary

With Executive

  • Impeach of Prez
  • Removal of judges.
  • Punish for breach of its privilege
  • Ministers are members of leg.
  • Prez Impeachment
  • Overlapping Powers Of  Executive

With Judiciary

With Legislative

  • Judicial app
  • Art 72 
  • Tribunals & QJBs— discharge judicial functions.
  • Ministers r members of Leg.
  • Ordinance
  • Delegated legislation.

Judicial pronouncements

  • KBC — SoP is part of basic structure
  • Indira Gandhi vs Raj Narain– In Indian Const, there is SoP in a broad sense only—A rigid SoP as in America does not apply to India
ALSO READ  Kanta Jangir IPS (UPSC) Wiki, Age, Caste, Boyfriend, Family, Biography, Marksheet, Rank, Optional, Date of Birth

Venkaih Naidu—All 3 organs should respect “jurisdictional sanctity enshrined in Const instead of arrogating to themselves a sense of supremacy”.